Pages

Friday

Manovich and the CAVE

In Lev Manovich’s Navigable Space (Language of New Media, 2002), he sets up a classical opposition between narrative thread and description of environment. Until the introduction of new media into the world of games, literature, and art, the focus of a piece was either on its plot or on its descriptive environment, though description was generally believed to detract from the narrative and was thus eliminated. However, the introduction of new media, especially Virtual Reality, changed the distinction between the two. In VR, the user’s exploration of space is necessary to the narrative and to the definition of the space: nothing will happen if the user is passive. Thus, the viewer becomes the central subject of the piece, the reason for its creation. Manovich writes,

“This focus on the viewer offers an important lesson for new media designers, who often forget that what they are designing is not an object in itself but a viewer’s experience in time and space” (Manovich, 267).

The CAVE illustrates the necessity and focus on the viewer/user (vuser); the vuser is literally in the center of the piece. Further, the structure of the CAVE is designed around the human body. It is eight cubic feet, accommodating the vuser comfortably; the tracking wand is designed for either the right hand or the left hand; and the stereovision glasses take into account the way our eyes render space in three dimensions. However, while a CAVE piece relies on the vuser and his/her interaction for narrative and spatial success, this interaction is tempered by the vuser’s consciousness of the virtuality and the alienating situation of the space itself.

Manovich complicates his argument for the vuser’s experience by questioning the structure of virtual space.

“[A]lthough 3-D computer-generated virtual worlds are usually rendered in linear perspective, they are really collections of separate objects unrelated to each other” (Manovich, 257).

We know on a structural level that VR is not in fact real, and we do not ask it to be. We, as vusers, as inter-actors, do not suspend disbelief in the virtuality of the reality. Again, the CAVE illustrates this argument. Imagine that a physical chair is put in the middle of the CAVE. Additionally, a jpeg file, programmed into the xml editor renders an image of an identical chair next to the physical one. A vuser must choose which to sit down in. We, as vusers, know that the rendering of the chair-image will not support our weight; we will always choose the physical chair. Though the space can give us 3-D realistic renderings, the vuser does not disregard the inherent virtuality of the space.

While an emphasis on the CAVE’s vuser interactivity and experience may seem to imply its anticipation of a wide audience, it is in fact shrouded in layers of privacy and inaccessibility. First, this particular CAVE is located in Brown University, itself a private and exclusive institution; on the University’s campus, many students have heard of the CAVE, but do not know what it is or where it is; the CAVEWriting class is capped at twelve students; the software interface is particularly opaque; one needs card swipe access and needs to remove one’s shoes to enter the room that the CAVE is in; a thick, dark curtain surrounds the CAVE itself; one must wear stereovision glasses in order to have the proper experience, and even then, only one pair of glasses determines the CAVE’s perspective. In short, the physical situation of the CAVE is both alienating and inaccessible to its audience. The vuser may be a necessary central subject of the CAVE, if s/he can get there at all.

Manovich stresses the importance of vuser interactivity and experience for all VR objects: the vuser is an active bridge between narrative and spatial representation. However, this interaction is informed by the virtual nature of the space; the vuser is not expected to interact with the space as if it were a physical, tangible, realistic environment; the emphasis is on the structural amalgamation of ‘separate objects’ (dependant on individual pieces of code): the virtuality and unreality.

Finally, to return to the question of the physical chair and the chair-image in the CAVE, why does the vuser know to choose the physical chair? How does s/he perceptually distinguish between the two? First, on a technical level, the CAVE’s software is old; the rendering of the chair is imperfect. The second reason is the role of light: our eyes can distinguish the difference between a projected image and a physical object (perceptible due to light bouncing off of it). But theoretically, if technology could produce a perfectly identical rendering of a chair, if VR was asked to deny its virtuality, we wouldn’t know which chair would hold weight, and human relationships and interactions with VR, with technology, would be forced to evolve.